Screening questions that ask for free consulting: what to give
Some screening questions ask for the answer itself, such as "What are the key cost drivers, and how will pricing change over the next three years?" Show that you can answer it, not the answer. Say where you sat, when, at what scale and which decisions were yours, give one fact only someone in that seat would know, and keep the analysis for the paid call.
Experts raise this often. Threads on the r/expertnetworks forum include how to deal with screening questions asking for free insights, asking the meaningful questions as part of the screening and detailed screener questions. Where this guide describes networks' terms, it is general information, not legal advice.
Why do some screening questions ask for so much?
Because the client is choosing between experts and wants evidence, and the quickest way to test someone is to ask the real question. It is rarely bad faith. But a long written answer to the real question is the call's content, delivered before anyone has agreed to pay for it.
Network terms tie payment to the consultation, not to the screening. Guidepoint's advisor terms say you will not be paid for a consultation unless it was completed, and that you should do no more than 15 minutes of preparatory work for a project without its explicit approval. GLG's member terms say that, unless GLG agrees otherwise in writing or the project invitation says so, you are paid only for the time you spend interacting with clients, and not for preparation time. So an hour spent on a screener is an hour no one has agreed to pay for, and the client may still pick someone else.
What is the difference between qualifying and answering?
Qualifying shows the client that you are the right person to ask. Answering gives them what they would have asked you on the call. A good screening answer is almost all qualifying, with just enough substance to prove it is real.
Qualifying is:
- your role, the years, and how close you were to the decision
- the scale: budget, sites, volumes, team
- one concrete detail that only someone in that seat would know
- what you can speak to, and where your first-hand knowledge stops
Answering is:
- the ranked list of drivers, and why
- figures for the market, not for your own role
- a forecast or a recommendation
- a comparison of named suppliers or competitors
What does that look like in practice?
Two invented examples, in fields chosen only to show the shape. Every name and figure in them is made up.
Hospital cleaning contracts
Question: What are the key cost drivers for contract cleaning companies serving hospitals, and how do you expect pricing to change over the next three years?
Giving the call away: A full page on labour as a share of cost, wage rules by region, consumables, how tenders are scored, which suppliers are losing share, and a three-year price forecast.
Qualifying: Yes, from the buying side. From 2017 to 2023 I ran facilities procurement for a group of five hospitals and managed our cleaning contract, around 9 million euros a year, through two tenders. I can take you through how the cost build-up looked from our side, what moved price at each renewal, and how I would expect buyers to react to the next round. I did not work for a cleaning company, so I know their margins only from negotiations.
Cold-chain logistics
Question: Which temperature-controlled carriers are winning share with grocery retailers, and why?
Giving the call away: A ranked list of carriers with reasons, their pricing, and which retailers each one serves.
Qualifying: Partly. Until 2024 I was head of transport for a regional grocery chain with about 120 stores, and I chose and managed our chilled and frozen carriers. I can explain what we weighed when we switched carriers in 2022 and what I heard from carriers bidding for the work. I can speak to our region, not to national share figures.
How do you say "on the call" without sounding difficult?
Say it in one plain sentence, after the qualifying part: "Happy to go through the drivers in detail on the call." It reads as confidence, not as holding back, because the rest of your answer has just shown the client you can. Keep the tone friendly: the client reads your answer as a preview of the call.
If a screener is long, or most of it asks for analysis, tell the network's project manager before you start writing. Ask whether the client would like to book a call, or whether the network can turn the questions into paid work. Guidepoint's 15-minute limit on unapproved preparation gives you a reason to ask that is not about money.
What should never go in a screening answer, however short?
Your current or former employer's confidential information, and material non-public information about any company. That applies to a three-line screening answer as much as to a call. Talk about patterns, ranges and how decisions get made, never a company's unreleased numbers, contract terms or plans.
The client's questions can be confidential too. Guidepoint's terms list the questions a client asks among the confidential information you must protect, and Third Bridge's expert terms count the subject of a consultation and the questions asked during it as confidential. So don't paste a screener into a public forum or a chatbot when you ask for advice on it; describe it in general words. For more, see how to answer expert network screening questions.
Can you use AI to write a long screener for you?
Check your network's rules first, because several cover written answers. GLG's Code of Conduct says members may not use or rely on AI-generated content in written responses to project opportunities, other than as GLG builds AI into its own systems, and Third Bridge's Expert Code of Conduct bars using any form of AI to answer, or help answer, its or its clients' questions. A short qualifying answer in your own words is quicker to write anyway. See what the rules say about AI.
How Consilyn fits
Consilyn is a live answer screen, in your browser on Windows and Mac, built on the screening answers you submit. On calls where it is allowed and the client has agreed, it transcribes the call on your laptop, never saving the audio, and shows short answers to read aloud, built from your screening answers and background notes. Every AI-written answer is marked not verified; where it uses your own words, a green label names the source and quotes them.
The call's text and your notes go to Google Gemini using your own key, and on Gemini's free tier Google may use that text to improve its products and people may review it. Consilyn does not decide whether a call allows it: your network's terms and your client do, so check your network's current terms before you use it.
For calls where it is allowed
Consilyn runs in your browser on Windows and Mac and shows short answers built from your screening answers and background, each labelled with its source, on calls your network allows and your client agrees to. Audio never leaves your laptop.
Start free in your browser